FYI, I'm not saying that the language contained in the PA regulations is
the best or appropriate to CA. What I've heard is that the result
of the regulations and practice in PA have accomplished what we have been
trying to do in CA - allow farmers to use urban organics more.
At 06:01 PM 6/19/2007, Dan Knapp wrote:
Hello all:On-Farm Composting
(PA Dept. of Environmental Protection)
Regarding the regulations governing composting on farms in
I respectfully submit that using the word "waste" when what you
actually mean is "recycle nutrients" is just the worst
industrial positioning imaginable for composting. Wastes are
worthless, but nutrients, properly managed, can be quite
I've seen waste composting, and it wasn't pretty. I just remember
an unusually very smelly dirty mrf in Michigan somewhere and a big nearby
field on which was parked a forlorn compost turning machine with its
flails completely fouled and immobilized by film plastic bags. The
compost windrows were full of plastic and who knows what else. But
the field they sat on was a real field used for corn/soybean
rotation. That dirt got a big dose of garbage, some of which is
probably still there.
What does it matter that the materials have been discarded from one
source, so long as they can become valuable feedstocks after they've been
upgraded by recovery enterprises to market specs? Clean in, Clean
out. Source separation is best practice. Nutrient recycling
is best positioning. Regulations should say what we want, not just
what we don't want. And farmers using clean nutrient recycling
practices should be regulated least, not most.
Regulations need to be rewritten top to bottom to remove waste management
vocabulary, which stifles and retards ecologically superior disposal
methods. There are better ways to talk about what we do.
Thanks for the chance to comment.
Urban Ore, Inc., a Berkeley reuse and recycling business.
On Jun 19, 2007, at 4:44 PM, Gary Liss wrote:
Consider the regulations governing composting on farms in
Pennsylvania. That's supposed to be a model:
Also, check out the following fact sheets and
On-Farm Composting Handbook by the Natural Resource,
Agriculture, and Engineering Service at Cornell University:
On-Farm Composting Fact Sheet, Penn State, Agricultural
At 03:47 PM 6/19/2007, Stephanie Barger wrote:
You might want to check with some
Fetzer wines uses alot of composting
and we just had Strauss Family Farms speak at our Zero Waste event and
they get 95% of all their energy from their manure and then use the
residual for composting!
Stephanie Barger, Executive Director
Earth Resource Foundation
P.O. Box 12364
Costa Mesa, CA 92627
"Learn more about Zero Waste! Presentations from Earth
Resource Foundation's Second Annual Orange County "Zero In on Zero
Waste: Don't Let Your Bottom Line Go to Waste" Conference on June
7th, 2007 are posted
mailto:email@example.com] On Behalf Of Wonsidler,
Sent: Wednesday, May 09, 2007 9:22 AM
Subject: [CRRA] Ordinances that facilitate on-farm composting
The County of San Diego is discussing revising local
ordinances to promote on-farm composting. Our region has a strong
agricultural community (Over 6,000 farms, ranks 5th in nation
in agricultural value), however our current local regulations are
restrictive when it comes to composting at farms. As a vital part of an
comprehensive organic materials management strategy, we view returning
organic materials to farms as ideal locations to encourage composting.
Can anyone send information on jurisdictions with
ordinances that promote on farm composting? We'd like to review model
ordinances before considering crafting our own.
Thanks for any leads!
County of San Diego
Waste Planning and Recycling
5469 Kearny Villa Road | Suite 305 |
San Diego, California 92123
Sober living environment
How to save the environment
Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email:
Switch delivery to Daily Digest |
Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo!